Even the guys who don’t get an opportunity to make much of an impact matter. Their presence on the roster provides peace of mind, insurance for the manager should something crazy happen during a game. And crazy things happen during World Series games all the time.
MORE: Why the Dodgers will win | Why the Astros will win
With that thought, we decided to rank not just the top 25 or 30 players on the World Series rosters, but all 50. The idea was to mesh talent, opportunity and performance and come up with a ranking that, admittedly, was never going to be perfect but would try to show how these guys stack up against one another.
So let’s jump in, shall we?
World Series player rankings
- Juan Centeno, Astros 49. Derek Fisher, Astros 48. Luke Gregerson, Astros 47. Joc Pederson, Dodgers 46. Joe Musgrove, Astros 45. Francisco Liriano, Astros 44. Tony Watson, Dodgers 43. Brandon McCarthy, Dodgers 42. Cameron Maybin, Astros 41. Charlie Culberson, Dodgers
Thoughts: The list of the best 50 players on a World Series roster has to start somewhere, right? So we’ll start with the third-string catcher for the Astros, the “break glass in case of emergency” playoff contributor who can go from afterthoughts to incredibly important with one injury. After Centeno, we have a collection of reserves who haven’t/won’t see much action (hi, Derek FIsher!) and guys who struggled in both the regular season and the playoffs (hi, Joc Pederson!). There’s one pitcher who hasn’t thrown a pitch all postseason (hi, Brandon McCarthy!) We also have a couple of relievers who could be called on to get big outs, so it feels wrong to have them so far down on the list (hi, Tony Watson and Joe Musgrove!), but these guys have to fit somewhere on the list, and it’s here. As for Charlie Culberson, he was fantastic in the NLCS (5-for-11, two doubles and a triple), but Corey Seager’s back on the roster, which means Culbertson’s role could be very diminished.
- Collin McHugh, Astros 39. Tony Cingrani, Dodgers 38. Ross Stripling, Dodgers 37. Chase Utley, Dodgers 36. Carlos Beltran, Astros 35. Andre Ethier, Dodgers 34. Yasmani Grandal, Dodgers 33. Will Harris, Astros 32. Logan Forsythe, Dodgers 31. Josh Fields, Dodgers
Thoughts: Lots of veterans in this section. Beltran has long been one of baseball’s best “hasn’t won a World Series yet” players, and he’s an important part of Houston’s lineup … in Houston. He’s down on this list a bit, though, because he’s DH/PH-only at this point in his career, which means limited playing time when the games are in Los Angeles. Utley won a title with the Phillies, but Ethier has spent his entire career with the Dodgers waiting for No. 1. Maybin is the type of player who can impact a game late with his speed on the bases. Grandal, a left-handed hitter, will have a chance to contribute against Verlander and McCullers. McHugh could be interesting in this series; he’s been a starter his entire career, but with the addition of Justin Verlander and McHugh’s injury issues this season, he’s been in the bullpen for the playoffs. He’s the type of innings-eater who could play a huge role, though, in a seven-game series.
MORE: Five things to watch between the Astros and Dodgers
- Brad Peacock, Astros 29. Evan Gattis, Astros 28. Kenta Maeda, Dodgers 27. Josh Reddick, Astros 26. Alex Wood, Dodgers 25. Enrique Hernandez, Dodgers 24. Chris Devenski, Astros 23. Austin Barnes, Dodgers 22. Charlie Morton, Astros 21. Marwin Gonzalez, Astros
Thoughts: Most of the Astros in this section — specifically Peacock, Reddick, Devenski and Gonzalez — have struggled more in the postseason than they did during outstanding regular-season campaigns. The playoffs are still a relatively small sample size, though, so we’re not banishing them to the bottom of this list. Hernandez, of course, had the epic three-homer game against the Cubs in the NLCS-clinching Game 5, and Barnes has been a pleasant surprise for L.A. this season.
- Ken Giles, Astros 19. Brian McCann, Astros 18. Brandon Morrow, Dodgers 17. Rich Hill, Dodgers 16. Alex Bregman, Astros 15. Corey Seager, Dodgers 14. Dallas Keuchel, Astros 13. Yuli Gurriel, Astros 12. Cody Bellinger, Dodgers 11. Yu Darvish, Dodgers
Thoughts: Let’s start with this: If we knew Seager was completely healthy and ready to make a typical Corey Seager-type impact, he’d definitely have a top-10 spot. We don’t, though, and with two stacked rosters, this is where he winds up, behind a ton of talented players. And, yeah, it feels like Keuchel and Darvish are too low, too, right? Look at the guys in front of them, though. Gurriel had his struggles adjusting to life in the big leagues after spending the first decade of his career in Cuba, but he found himself in 2017 and has been spraying line drives all over the field in October. I’m not sure many folks outside of L.A. understand how important Morrow has been for the Dodgers this year. The right-hander had a 2.06 ERA/1.55 FIP in 45 regular-season appearances and he’s allowed just four baserunners in 8.1 postseason innings. Bregman and McCann teamed up for one of the most important outs at the plate in any October game (in Game 7 against the Yankees) and they’ve both come up with big hits for the Astros during the playoffs, too.
MORE: Astros playing with greater purpose after Hurricane Harvey
George Springer, Astros Springer’s one of those heart-and-soul-of-the-team guys who plays with passion — and a ton of talent. You saw his leaping catches in Games 6 and 7 of the ALCS, and he’s been solid as Houston’s leadoff hitter, too.
Yasiel Puig, Dodgers The man legendary Dodgers broadcaster Vin Scully loved to call “The Wild Horse” has been amazing during the postseason. Puig is hitting .417 with six RBIs, six runs scored and four extra-base hits (two doubles, a triple and a homer) in eight games. There was never a doubt Puig had the talent to lead the Dodgers to a World Series, and it’s been fun watching him actually make that happen.
Lance McCullers Jr., Astros We’ve said for a while that McCullers has the stuff to be a star on October’s bright stage, and he proved us right with a dominating performance in the ALCS. He limited the Yankees to two hits in six stellar innings in his Game 4 start, then closed out Game 7 by allowing only one hit in four shutout relief innings. The idea of trying to square up his curveball has to be giving the Dodgers nightmares.
Chris Taylor, Dodgers Zero people expected Taylor to become an essential piece of the Dodgers’ postseason success, but here he is, starting games in center field and at shortstop (while Seager was out in the NLCS) and being a pest at the plate and on the bases. In eight playoff games, he’s scored eight runs and has five extra-base hits: two homers, two doubles and a triple.
Justin Turner, Dodgers Getting Turner out was a huge problem for both the Diamondbacks and Cubs. He’s driving the ball with authority (and has been for a couple years now) but here’s an underrated Turner skill: He spoils lots of good two-strike pitches by fouling them off, which gives him the chance to do damage with a better pitch later in the count.
Carlos Correa, Astros The kid’s a superstar. Correa, who just turned 23 in September, was in the AL MVP conversation before he missed several weeks with a thumb injury. He has a .931 OPS in the postseason with three homers, four doubles and nine RBIs in 11 games.
MORE: Catch up on the old rivalry between the Astros and Dodgers
Clayton Kershaw, Dodgers Kershaw is the best starting pitcher in baseball, and he has been for quite a while now. That’s not really up for debate. Think about this: He has a 1.95 ERA in the past five regular seasons (141 starts). That’s insane. It’s also true that Kershaw has had his share of playoff hiccups, including a four-homer start against Arizona in the NLDS. He was brilliant in the NLCS-clincher against the Cubs last week, allowing just three hits and one run in six innings in Game 5.
Justin Verlander, Astros The veteran right-hander has been everything the Astros could have possibly hoped for when they acquired him moments before the deadline for players to be playoff-eligible. After a 1.06 ERA in five regular-season starts with Houston, Verlander has a 1.46 ERA in 24.2 playoff innings. This is the type of impact GMs dream of their acquisitions making.
Kenley Jansen, Dodgers Yes, I’ll admit, this feels high for a relief pitcher. But when Jansen enters a playoff game for the Dodgers, the game is over. Done. In the 2017 postseason, Jansen has 12 strikeouts in eight innings; he’s allowed only four base runners and one unearned run. Want more numbers? He’s never blown a playoff save in his career, and five of those 11 postseason saves have been more than three outs. Jansen’s faced 111 hitters in his postseason career, and he’s struck out 47 of them, against only 14 hits allowed. In 24 career playoff relief appearances, he’s allowed an earned run only twice. In October, it’s hard to get better than automatic, and Jansen’s automatic. He’s the single-most automatic player on this list.
Jose Altuve, Astros Altuve has been one of baseball’s best players for several years, and he’ll likely be the AL MVP after batting .346 with 24 home runs, 32 stolen bases, a .957 OPS and 8.3 WAR. And he’s shown this month that he’s not intimidated by the playoff stage, either. Altuve hit three homers in Game 1 of the ALDS, and he’s batting .400 with a .500 on-base percentage and 1.275 OPS so far this postseason.
